Proper 24, Yr A (2026) The Rev. Karen C. Barfield
Matthew 22:15-22 St. Andrew’s Episcopal Church
In the name of the one, holy, and loving God:
Creator, Redeemer, and Sanctifying Spirit. Amen.
Journalist Anthony Breznican tells the following story:
“I grew up loving Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood…
But it wasn't until I had a chance encounter with Fred Rogers as an adult
that I realized the character he played on TV wasn’t fake.
“Fred Rogers was from Pittsburgh, my hometown,
and I’m a member of just one generation that grew up loving this man,
who taught us to be kind above all
and see ourselves as special and good,
no matter what the world tried to tell us to the contrary….
“Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood ran until 2001,
but I lost touch with it as I got older.
“That’s how it goes.
“But in college, one day, I rediscovered it,
just when I needed it.
“I was having a hard time then.
The future seemed hopeless.
“I was struggling, lonely, dealing with a lot of broken pieces within myself,
and not adjusting well.
“I was a student at the University of Pittsburgh but felt rudderless….”
“Walking out of the dorm one morning,
I heard familiar music in the hallway:
Won’t you be my neighbor?....
“The TV was playing in an empty common room…
and there he was – the sweatered one,
feeding his fish,
checking in with that little trolley that rolled through the wall
into the Neighborhood of Make-Believe,
and asking me what I do with the mad that I feel….
“Several days later, I got in the elevator…
and who was standing there but Mr. Rogers.
For real.”
Anthony then relates how he stood there dumbfounded,
just staring at Mr. Rogers,
trying to find the courage to speak and awkwardly nodded instead.
As the elevator doors opened and they stepped into the lobby,
he finally blurts out:
“Mr. Rogers…I don’t mean to bother you.
But I just wanted to say thanks.
“He smiled patiently.
I imagine this sort of thing happened to him about every 10 feet.
“Then he said,
‘Did you grow up as one of my television neighbors?’”
“I felt like crying.
“Yeah.
I did.
I was his neighbor.
“He opened his arms,
lifting his satchel in the air,
and beckoning me in said,
‘It’s good to see you again, neighbor.’”
Anthony and Mr. Rogers chatted through the lobby to the front door,
and as Mr. Rogers opened the door to leave,
Anthony again blurted out that he’d recently stumbled on the show
at a time when he truly needed it.
“So…thanks for that.
Again,” he said.
“Mr. Rogers nodded.
He looked down,
and let the door close again.
“He undid his scarf and motioned to the window,
where he sat down on the ledge.
“He said, ‘Do you want to tell me what was upsetting you?’
“So I sat.
And I told him the truth.”
I told him the truth.
Telling the truth can be hard,
and elusive oftentimes.
In today’s gospel story,
we hear a different kind of conversation.
We encounter a story that gets at truth in the end
but does not seek truth from those who initiate the conversation.
Today’s gospel story begins this way:
“The Pharisees went and plotted to entrap Jesus in what he said.”
The Pharisees and Herodians begin their conversation
with false flattery and insincerity:
“Teacher, we know that you are sincere….”
The Pharisees and Herodians lie on each side of the “yes” or “no” answer to the question they propose to Jesus, so either way he answers, one group will be angry with him.
It’s a “catch-22” proposition,
and they know it.
They aren’t really interested in genuine conversation.
They aren’t really interested in plumbing the depths of their faith.
They aren’t really interested in learning something
that might transform their lives.
Instead, they want to trip up Jesus and get him out of their way.
Jesus responds to them bluntly,
“Why are you putting me to the test, you hypocrites?”
You “hypocrites”…those who have taken to wearing a false likeness…
those who have forgotten in whose image they were made…
the very image of God.
“Tell us, Jesus, …is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor, or not?”
Well, Jesus asks,
whose head – whose likeness –
is on the coin?
The emperor’s!
Then give to the emperor the things that are the emperor’s
and to God the things that are God’s.
Somewhere along the way,
the Pharisees seem to have lost sight of the fact that Yahweh,
the God of Israel,
the God of the Pharisees,
is walking in their midst.
They seem to have forgotten that they themselves
have been made in the very image of God…
that the whole of their lives belong to God,
and that they themselves reflect the goodness and mercy of God.
They seem to have forgotten that God will walk with them
in the midst of their fear and insecurity and pain.
They have forgotten that they need not wield power over and against others
in order to secure themselves.
They have forgotten that their identity and security rests in God’s goodness.
In flattering Jesus they say,
“Teacher, we know that you are sincere,
and teach the way of God in accordance with truth,
and show deference to no one;
for you do not regard people with partiality.”
They speak the truth
but do not live as if it were true!
You see, Jesus reflected God’s light,
and that was a threat to the people in power.
Mr. Rogers also reflected God’s light.
What I love about this story of Mr. Rogers and Anthony’s encounter with him
is the connection of two people honoring truth through vulnerability.
This is exactly what Jesus offers,
and the Pharisees missed it.
Anthony continued his reflections on the witness of Mr. Rogers:
“I never realized when I was little
that when Mr. Rogers sat with his feet in the cool water of a pool
and invited the singing cop, Officer Clemmons, to join him
that that was a daring statement about equality
[remember this show aired beginning in 1968].
“It seemed like no big deal to me.
I suppose now that was the point.
“A white man and a black man,
chilling out on a hot day with their feet in the water –
so simple,
such a little thing,
but brave in its sweetness….
“Mr. Rogers saw people.
“He saw through and around the things that confuse or distract others.
“He saw these people.
“He saw me,
a struggling young man who needed some kind words.”
(Anthony Breznican, “The real Mr. Rogers” in The Week: The Best of the U.S. and International Media, Oct 20, 2017, pp 36-37)
Considering Jesus’ encounter with the Pharisees and the Herodians
(and everyone else for that matter), I wonder:
How is it that we render to God what is God’s,
which is to say…ourselves?
All that we are and all that we have?
How do we reflect the image of God through our very lives?
This week the vestry is hosting some listening sessions
so that we can discern and speak what our values are…
as the community of St. Andrew’s.
Through which values do we most reflect the Light of Christ?
The story is told that Francis of Assisi offered this invitation on his deathbed:
“I have done what is mine to do.
May Christ teach you what is yours.”
Discerning who we are:
what gifts we have been given to share…
how we are called to reflect the Light and Love of Christ in the world…
these are important conversations to have and to keep having.
I invite you to stay today after church, if you are able,
and listen to the movement of the Spirit among us.
I pray that we may receive the Grace to see with our eyes and our hearts,
that we and all our neighbors have been created in God’s image…
so that we may reflect God’s light
and offer the whole of our lives and our love
for the furthering of God’s kindom. Amen.